Now What? Making the Final Decision.

Shelly Humbach • April 23, 2019

[source: NACAC]


It’s almost here! The National Candidates Reply Date for U.S. colleges is May 1. As a senior, this is your enrollment decision deadline. If you did not do an Early Decision application, you may still be weighing your options. How do you approach this final, important decision? Cyndy McDonald, college counseling expert, shared some tips in a webinar, “Now What? Making the Final Decision.”

Preparation
Review your answers to the College Match survey, by Dr. Steven Antonoff, included in GuidedPath. Knowing your preferences and traits is important as you prioritize your admission offers. If you have not taken the survey yet, you can still do it now!


  • What are your top 3 categories?
  • In your own words, describe what your highest score category says about you and your needs for going to college?

Parents Must Contribute
Going to college is a family affair. You are going to college, but your parents are sending you. It should be as good a fit for your whole family. Involve your parents and take their opinions to heart when making your final college decision.

As a Family Review Best Fit Categories
Together as a family, think back to what was most important to you when making your original list of colleges (things like - academics, location, size, activities). Evaluate which college meets your needs best?

Four aspects of “best fit”.

1. Academic: Does it offer your major or field of study? Internships or cooperative educational options? What will your class sizes be? Compare the number of undergraduate students at each college.

2. Financial: Is it affordable, both for you and your family? Will you need student loans to afford the school? Have you been offered generous scholarships or grants? Do a cost comparison to see which colleges offer you the best financial aid. Details for doing financial award comparisons are in previous emails.

3. Social: Harlan Cohen, author of “The Naked Roommate” talks about the importance of identifying PEOPLE and PLACES you will feel comfortable with on campus (see Harlan’s webinar, 7 Big Mistakes HS Seniors Make When Picking a College ) . Who will your people and places be? One of the best ways to do this is an overnight visit on campus.

4. Physical: Based on your college visits, which college offers the physical location that best fits your needs? Does the physical campus environment excite you? What about the climate and the surrounding area?

Ask for Opinions
Before you make a final decision, talk to others. Check social media. Talk to friends at the schools you are considering. Find out what the pros and cons are for each campus from students there. Use Niche or Unigo to view student reviews about the campus.

Make a list of Pros and Cons
Using the information in your rankings, create a list of pros and cons for each school and enter them into the Decisions section of GuidedPath. Use this information and your review of categories to determine which college you are enrolling as a freshman in the fall.

Looking forward with Enthusiasm
Once you make your enrollment decision, look forward with enthusiasm, and don’t second guess yourself. You can do well at any of the colleges on your list. It is all up to you to make it happen. The college name is less important than the experiences you will have while there!

By Shelly Humbach September 11, 2025
In June, I hosted my annual Senior Essay Writing Workshop. This was the first in-person workshop since 2019. I bet you can guess why. I was elated to meet my students face-to-face after months, even years, of connecting through the screen. Imagine my surprise at their height, super-smiles, and warm laughter. Dang, it was wonderful. So, essentially, all my in-state seniors gather at my house for a three-hour intensive workshop on crafting a killer college essay. As I was preparing for the event, it occurred to me that I might be in competition with their PHONE. Classic directness (this is probably a character flaw) led me to inform my students and their parents, in advance, that this would be a no-phone gathering. My messaging went something like this, Important: Phones are placed in a basket at the door and retrieved at noon. No exceptions. Parents: If you need to reach your student during the workshop, text me directly at **********. Now, I am fully on board with the phone-free movement. I support it, advocate for it, and live it (I brilliantly quit all personal media last November). And I thought: my event, my rules. I was a little concerned about how this announcement would land. Turns out my concern was mainly about the parents. The kids? Not so much. In fact, research indicates that students crave phone-free learning environments. Suffice to say, the workshop was a smashing success. Not a single student pushed back against the policy. One poor soul forgot to retrieve her phone and left it sitting all alone in the basket. Not to worry, though. She didn’t get far before turning back to grab it. Here’s the truth: We don’t have to bow down to every technological whim or societal pressure. As adults, we know the phone is a problem, and it’s our job to foster healthy, happy individuals. So let's keep this momentum going. As Maya Angelou wisely said, “When you know better, do better.”
By Shelly Humbach August 11, 2025
I work with incredible colleagues; collaborative, smart and supportive. They make me better and I am deeply grateful. Every year, Jennie Kent and Jeff Levy of Big J Educational Consulting share invaluable information regarding college admissions. Their research is impeccable and accurate and provides crucial data to help students and families make informed college decisions. Read on, share broadly and give a shout out to these generous professionals! Early Decision and Regular Decision Acceptance Rates Class of 2028 Domestic Undergraduate Need-Based and Merit Aid Class of 2028 In-State and Out-of-State Acceptance Rates Class of 2028 Financial Aid for International Noncitizens Class of 2028 International Noncitizens Acceptance Rate and Yield Class of 2028 Percentage of Students Submitting SAT and ACT Scores Class of 2028 Athletic Divisions and Conferences (partial list) Class of 2028 - NEW! These charts are visual, interactive, and easy to use. They make it possible to instantly sort using any column's metrics and to easily compare subsets of colleges. They are free and can be accessed at www.bigjeducationalconsulting.com/resources . From Jennie and Jeff: We hope you find these resources helpful in your work guiding students. Please feel free to share them broadly as long as they remain in their original unedited form. Permission is not granted to those charging a fee for their distribution. If you find an error after cross-referencing with an institution's Common Data Set, please contact us at info@bigjconsult.com . Thank you!
By Shelly Humbach July 17, 2025
The Power of Paying Attention
By Shelly Humbach June 11, 2025
Parents: Before Your Student Launches,  Get These Legal Docs in Place
By Shelly Humbach May 14, 2025
Is Your Student Ready For College?
By Shelly Humbach April 16, 2025
Wait for it……they should be having fun.
By Shelly Humbach October 23, 2023
"The Common Application, often referred to as The Common App is an online platform that facilitates the college application process for students."
By Shelly Humbach October 23, 2023
"The AXS Companion provides step-by-step guidance, tips, and expert advice to help you tackle every section of the Common App with confidence."
understanding financial aid: everything you need to know
By Shelly Humbach April 27, 2023
Navigating Financial Aid can be a confusing process. Make sure you understand the financial terminology before entering the lengthy process of applying for scholarships and financial aid. Learn more in this comprehensive guide.
By Shelly Humbach February 24, 2023
In the Spirit of - More College Admissions Fun - Let’s talk about Deferrals
More Posts